1976
The Odd Couple
Godspell

1977
Streetcar Named Desire
Barefoot in the Park
Glass Menagerie
Adaptation

1978
You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown
Pale Pink Dragon
Dial M for Murder
Winnie the Pooh
Arms and the Man

1979
Play It Again Sam
Music Man
King Cole and the Country Witches
The Odd Couple
I Do! I Do!
Ten Little Indians
A Funny Thing ? Forum
A Thousand Clowns
Here’s Love

1980
Twelfth Night
Cabaret
1776
Same Time, Next Year
The Fantasticks
The Runner Stumbles
Little Mary Sunshine
Vanities

1981
Prisoner of Second Avenue
Stop the World, I Want to Get Off
The Mousetrap
The Mikado
House at Pooh Corner

1982
Godspell
Wind in the Willows
Romantic Comedy
Pippin
Arsenic and Old Lace
The Pirates of Penzance
Man of La Mancha
Shadow Box
The Messiah

1983
Morning’s at Seven
A View From the Bridge
Kiss Me Kate
The Seven Year Itch
South Pacific
I Ought to be in Pictures
HMS Pinafore
Snoopy
Fiddler on the Roof

1984
Jacques Brel
Charlotte’s Web
Grease
They’re Playing Our Song
You Can’t Take it With You
Hide and Seek
Iolanthe
Sweet Charity
Camelot

1985
Peter Pan
Anything Goes
Sound of Music
California Suite
Sleuth
The Gondoliers
Antigone
Best of Broadway and Beyond

1986
Winnie the Pooh
Miracle Worker
My Fair Lady
Dracula
Don’t Drink the Water
Sweeney Todd
Spoon River Anthology
Babes in Toyland

1987
Raggedy Ann and Andy
George M
Gypsy
Present Laughter
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Best Little Whorehouse in Texas
Some Enchanted Evening
Diary of Anne Frank
Annie

1988
Hansel and Gretel
Brighton Beach Memoirs
Oklahoma
The Mikado
Mr. Roberts
Up the Down Staircase
Gift of the Magi/Scrooge

1989
The Velveteen Rabbit
A Funny Thing?Forum
Biloxi Blues
Annie Get Your Gun
The Odd Couple (female)
A Chorus Line
Tartuffe
The Fabulous Fable Factory
Anne of Green Gables

1990
Aladdin
Godspell
Broadway Bound
Crimes of the Heart
Brigadoon
You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
Into the Woods

1991
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Jesus Christ Superstar
1940’s Radio Hour
No, No Nanette
West Side Story
A Midsummer Night’s Dream
The Arkansaw Bear
The King and I

1992
Big River
Pinocchio
Steel Magnolias
Grease
Noises Off
Death of a Salesman
America Before Columbus
Oliver

1993
Nunsense
Wind in the Willows
Romeo and Juliet
Something’s Afoot
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
Charlie’s Aunt
Love Letters
Stuart Little
Peter Pan

1994
Anything Goes
Bodhi and the Rainforest
To Kill a Mockingbird
Pump Boys and Dinettes
Guys & Dolls
Jacques Brel
Charlotte’s Web
Meet Me in St. Louis

1995
Forever Plaid
Really Rosie
The Secret Garden
Bye Bye Birdie
Hello Dolly!
Jake’s Women
The Fabulous Fable Factory
Annie Warbucks

1996
Will Rogers Follies
Raggedy Ann and Andy
Runaways
Damn Yankees
Crazy For You
I Do! I Do!
Once Upon a Shoe
The Music Man

1997
Fiddler on the Roof
The Dancing Spider
The Boyfriend
Forever Plaid
42nd Street
The Tafettas
The Adventures of Nate the Great
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

1998
The Fantasticks
Mr. Popper’s Penguins
Lend Me a Tenor
A Chorus Line
Little Shop of Horrors
The Mousetrap
The Universe and Other Stuff
Finian’s Rainbow

1999
The Sound of Music
Schoolhouse Rock, Live
Lost in Yonkers
Nunsense Jamboree
West Side Story
The Foreigner
Free to Be You and Me
Children of Eden

2000
Man of La Mancha
Starblast
The Miracle Worker
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
Fame
Moon Over Buffalo
On Time
Nuncrackers

2001
Evita
Alice in Wonderland
The Nerd
Tall Tales and Heroes
Mame

2002
Chicago
The Velveteen Rabbit
Rumors
Company
Footloose
1776
Stuart Little
Scrooge

2003
Funny Girl
Once on This Island Jr.
Baby
The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940
Good News
Scapino
The Fabulous Fable Factory
Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

2004
Cabaret
Charlotte's Web
Godspell
Steel Magnolias
Carousel
Radio Gals
How to Eat Like a Child
Inspecting Carol

2005
Jesus Christ Superstar
Honk Jr.
Leader of the Pack
A Little Night Music
Babes in Arms
Clue, the Musical
Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day
Beauty and the Beast

2006
Big River
Disney's Aladdin Jr.
Urinetown: The Musical
The Who's Tommy
Noises Off
Miss Nelson is Missing
A Broadway Christmas

2007
Smokey Joe's Cafe
Seussical Jr.
Pirates of Penzance
Thoroughly Modern Millie
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
Miss Nelson Has a Field Day
The King and I

2008
Buddy: The Buddy Holly Story
Disney's Alice in Wonderland, Jr.